Questions and Answers from Joel

Many of us enjoy the classes in which Joel answers questions from students.  Sometimes the question is one that we ourselves might have asked.  Other times it is one that might not have occurred to us, but which we find interesting, and we are curious about how Joel will answer it.

On this page of our website, on the first and third Saturdays of the month, we will post a new question and answer from one of Joel’s classes or books.  We trust that you will find these interesting, helpful, and sometimes an answer to just what is on your mind.

You can access previously posted questions by clicking on the links at the bottom of this page.

Posted on 10/17/20:

This excerpt is from Recording 137A, from the 1956 Melbourne Closed Class, “The Principles of ‘As’ and ‘Is’.'” It is posted with kind permission from the Estate of Joel S. Goldsmith, which holds the copy protection on the recorded classes and the copyright on the transcripts. The full transcript of this recording is available at www.joelgoldsmith.com or by calling 1-800-922-3195.

To download or print this Q and A, click here.

Q:  Is it not possible that the consciousness which is now filled with human concepts could become so purified and full of light that what appears as a human body would fade out from human sight, and therefore not have to go through the process called death?  Is it not because of the earthly consciousness that the body appears to die and dissolve into the earth?

A:  Yes, that is correct on both questions.  It is said that Moses disappeared from sight without having been buried.  It is said that Enoch disappeared from sight without having been buried.  And certainly, we have the story of Elijah, who to sense, ascended on a cloud.

Now it is possible that an individual may attain such a high state of spiritual consciousness that what appears as their human body actually disappears from sight as a human body.  But only those who are very close to that degree of spiritual awareness will know it.  As far as the rest of the world is concerned, they still will see it as a body being left for burial, because remember, they will be seeing the universal concept.  They will not be seeing that which is, they will be seeing their concept of that which is.

In other words, if we had Jesus present here walking on the water, that does not mean that all of the people on the shore would see him walking on the water.  As a matter of fact, you can be assured that only a very few would.  Those few would be those of spiritual consciousness, because as it says here, “earthly consciousness will see only an earthly concept.”  So even if you have made the transition without leaving a body behind, don’t think for a minute that the world would believe it.  The only ones who would believe it would be those of your own students, who had been lifted to the degree where they could apprehend it.

In other words, I told you of the experience where, in Seattle, we actually had the presence of the Christ in that room, tangibly experienced by over two hundred people.  But there were four hundred and fifty people in the room, and the others did not know that anything had happened.  Twice, we have had it happen in my classes that I have disappeared from the platform, and only a beam of light was left shining in the chair.  And on both occasions, only about four people witnessed it.  So only those of spiritual vision can behold a spiritual demonstration.

That is why, when Peter said, “Thou art the Christ,” the Master said, “Flesh and blood—that is, your eyesight, your intelligence, your ears—hath not told you this.  The Father within revealed it to you—meaning your spiritual consciousness, your Christhood.  In other words, “The Son of God which has been raised up in you realized the Christ in me. Otherwise, I would be just a Hebrew rabbi.”

In the same way when he took three of his disciples to the Transfiguration—why only three?   Why not twelve?  And if twelve, why not the two hundred?  Because the experience of the Transfiguration could only be witnessed by those in that highest consciousness, who have come to see that the past, the present, and the future are one, and therefore, all that has been, is now; all that ever will be, is now, and therefore, here in this “nowness” and “hereness,” I can behold the spiritual creation of the entire past, of the present, and of the future.

In that Seattle class experience, all that the students who had not been aware of this Christ experience wondered was why I had stopped talking in the middle of the class and waited a few minutes to resume.  They knew nothing that had happened in that interval, and yet there were about two hundred there who actually had the experience of witnessing the Christ.

So it has been that on numerous occasions during our classwork, some very remarkable things have happened of a spiritual nature, but in each case, not more than six or eight or nine students in the entire room were aware of it.  The rest were not aware that anything had taken place. They saw nothing and heard nothing.  To them it was just another class.  But to the six, eight, or nine who were high enough in Spirit, they actually witnessed something of what the world would call a miraculous nature.

So it is that I can assure you that if the Christ should appear in this room during our work, only those would behold It who are high enough in consciousness at that moment to behold a spiritual vision.  The rest would never know that anything had happened, and later would say, “Well I know it didn’t happen, because I was there.”

That is exactly why the Hebrew race does not accept the resurrection, because it is said that only about five hundred people actually witnessed the Master on earth after the crucifixion.  Yet you must remember that there were multitudes whom he had healed, multitudes whom he had fed, multitudes who listened to his sermons.  But we are told that only about five hundred witnessed that resurrection.

So you can be assured that all the rest said that it really didn’t happen, because they were there.  It must have been those of the five hundred who formed the foundation of the Christian movement; that is, the movement that left the Hebrew church after the crucifixion to follow the teachings of the Master.

So never for a moment believe that even if you were to make the transition, and like Elijah, mount on a cloud and disappear, do not believe for a minute that the world would say so in the newspapers the next day, because they would not be aware of it.  They would see a body, and they would bury a body.  It wouldn’t be a body; it would be the universal concept.  But they couldn’t rise higher than that concept.

That is one of the reasons we have disagreements in spiritual works, because since all are not on the same level of consciousness, all do not see the same thing and do not hear the same thing.  You would be surprised if you could know some of the things that I have heard people read into my books or hear in my classes that never took place.  But as far as they are concerned, they read it or heard it.  But of course, they didn’t.  They were just hearing their own concept, their own experience come back to them.

Previously Posted Questions and Answers

10/3/20: Could you please talk to us about the Circle of Christhood?

9/19/20:  When tempted to indulge in negative thoughts such as antagonism and so forth, what is the best way to cope with them and nullify the effects?

9/5/20:  All my life I have lived with a fear of some kind … and then it mentions different fears … and how can I overcome this?

8/15/20: Would you please explain the unreality of death and life eternal?

8/1/20: If God is present; if God already knows my need; if it is God’s good pleasure to give me the kingdom; then why am I not experiencing it? 

7/18/20: What is the difference, if any, between realization and illumination?

7/4/20: Please explain the term “the Christ” as it is used in our work.

6/20/20: How do we specifically annul the belief of heredity?

6/6/20:  How can I truly believe in medicines and [other] cures, and continue to [use them], secretly having a belief that they will ease and cure aches and pains?

5/16/20: Are trials proof of God’s care?

5/2/20: Please explain your statement “Realization is demonstration.”

4/18/20: Why do so many people who never think seriously of God or spiritual things find success and happiness and very often experience few or no problems?

4/4/20: Why is there so much sin, disease, death, and war on earth if there is such a God as is taught in the churches? Why are there crippled or stillborn children? 

3/21/20: Why should a person be “on the mountain top,” and then down in the depths?

3/7/20: Do we lose our identity when we return to God? 

2/15/20: Why is it that I have been studying for so long and achieved so little result? 

2/1/20: Please tell us something about the Transfiguration.

1/18/20: When we turn to God, when we are seeking divine guidance in our daily affairs, how do we know whether or not it is divine guidance?

1/4/20: Would you please explain in your own words this statement: “When we can look at a problem without running from it or struggling against it, this very problem ceases to exist”?

To view questions and answers posted in 2019, click here.
To view questions and answers posted in 2018, click here.
To view questions and answers posted in 2017, click here.
To view questions and answers posted in 2016, click here.